A second opinion means another specialist looks at your biopsy results, your PSA history and your scans before you decide what to do. It often confirms what you were already told. Sometimes it changes it. Dr. David Samadi reads your records himself and replies within two business days.

Why get a second opinion first?

You only get to make this decision once. Here is why it is worth a few days.

Your Gleason score might change. Grading is a judgment call. When a second pathologist reads the same slides, the score sometimes comes out different. That can change what treatment you need. Read how Gleason scores work.

You may not need surgery at all. Some prostate cancers grow so slowly that watching them closely is safer than treating them. You want a surgeon who will tell you that. Read about active surveillance.

Not all surgery is the same. How the surgery is done, and how many the surgeon has performed, can affect your chances of staying continent and keeping normal sexual function.

You cannot undo treatment. Once the prostate is removed or radiated, that decision is final. A second read of the same slides costs you nothing.

Waiting a few days is usually safe. Most prostate cancers grow slowly. Taking a week to be sure rarely changes the outcome. Ask your doctor if that is true in your case.

What do I need to send?

Most men do not have these on hand. You can request all of them from the office or hospital that did your biopsy. They have to give them to you.

Send whatever you have:

  • Your biopsy report from the pathologist
  • Your PSA results — all of them if you can, not just the most recent one
  • Any MRI or scan reports
  • The treatment your doctor has already recommended, if any
  • A short note about your age, any symptoms, and your other health conditions

A clear photo taken on your phone works fine. It does not need to be a scan.

How it works

1. Send your records. The form takes about ten minutes.

2. Dr. Samadi reviews them. He reads your pathology, your PSA history and your scans himself.

3. You talk it through. By phone, by video, or in person at our Madison Avenue office.

4. You decide. You leave with a clear summary of your options — whether or not you choose to be treated here.

Who is Dr. David Samadi?

Dr. Samadi is a board-certified urologist and cancer surgeon in New York City. He has performed more than 10,000 robotic prostate surgeries.

He trained at SUNY Stony Brook School of Medicine, completed his urology training at Montefiore, and did a urologic oncology fellowship at Memorial Sloan Kettering. He then trained in robotic prostate surgery in France under Professor Claude Abbou.

He sees patients in English, Spanish and Farsi.

More about Dr. Samadi.

If you live outside New York

You do not need to fly in for a second opinion. Send your records, and Dr. Samadi will review them and speak with you by phone or video.

If you decide to be treated here, our team helps with travel, hotels near the office, and letters for visa applications. More for patients travelling from abroad.

Send your records and Dr. Samadi will review them personally.

Start my second opinion review

Common questions

How long does it take?

Dr. Samadi replies within two business days of receiving your records. If anything is missing from what you send, the office will contact you to request it so the review is not delayed.

Do I have to come to New York?

No. Many men send their records and speak with Dr. Samadi by phone or video first. An in-person visit is arranged only if you decide to go further, and records can be reviewed from anywhere.

Will my current doctor find out?

Only if you tell them. Second opinions are routine and most doctors expect them. You are not obliged to explain yourself, and nothing is shared with your current doctor without your consent.

My surgery is already booked. Is it too late?

No. As long as you have not had the operation, your records can still be reviewed. Ask your doctor whether a short delay is safe in your case. For most men with prostate cancer it is, because these cancers usually grow slowly.